Type and press Enter.

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn

Just in time for Pride month, it’s a Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza!
Now that I have gotten my hands on a few more rainbow highlighters I can give you more swatches and my review on them. Spoiler alert: my favorite is still the same. If you want to read my previous post, feel free to click here and read my old review.

In this post I will show swatches of:
Devinah “Susperia” $18-25, comes in 3 pan sizes 32mm, 44 mm, and 57 mm
Chaos Makeup “Kaleidoscope” $26, comes in a seashell compact.
Bitter Lace Beauty “Prism” $22, 44mm pan
Wet N Wild Color Icon Rainbow Highlighter “Unicorn Glow” $5.99, 7.5 grams, .26 oz
Forever 21 Rainbow Highlighter $5.90, 6.8 grams, .239 oz
Ulta Rainbow Highlighter  $10, 7.36 grams, .26 oz
Love Luxe Beauty “What Unicorns Are Made Of” $12 for 2.8 grams and $15 for 5.5 grams

*If a link does not work, it means the product is sold out or the link has moved. The prices listed at the full retail price, some of them go on sale!

The Highlighters
Photos show the pan, outdoor sunlight, indoors during the day and under an artificial light. If the swatches look different to you, the outdoor photos were taken on a different day than the bottom indoor photos.

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! Devinah Cosmetics | I Need This Unicorn

Devinah Cosmetics “Susperia”

I really love Devinah’s Susperia because they are all light, white based pigments. On my skin tone (NC15) it is very flattering, and I tend to get away with wearing white highlighter. It looks really ethereal and subtle. I don’t feel weird wearing this out, casually in the day or on a night out. This is my second favorite of all of them.

Devinah also has a stronger rainbow called Unicorn Sweat. On their site, they specify that it is meant to be used as an eyeshadow because the colors are strong.


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! Chaos Makeup | I Need This Unicorn

Chaos Makeup “Kaleidoscope”

This one is hands down my favorite of all the rainbow highlighters I own. First of all, it’s small. That’s not bad, it’s preferred! It fits on my cheekbone. Also the pigments are more luminous. It just glows! The green, blue and purple are not too dark, which I prefer. In the two bottom squares in the photo above, my finger missed the purple. But you can see proper swatches of it later on in this post. I will also wear this casually running errands to a music festival to a fancy holiday party. I’ve worn it on my face and on my collar bones. And the fact that it’s small makes it possible!


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! Bitter Lace Beauty | I Need This Unicorn

Bitter Lace Beauty “Prism”

Also known as the original! It was definitely the first one I purchased.  If you only want to support the original, you can’t go wrong with this highlighter. I’ve worn this plenty of times. I like how my pan has a less green and a whole lot of purple. The yellow is the more prominent in the swatch and that’s just fine with me because I like a gold highlight.


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! Wet N Wild | I Need This Unicorn

Wet N Wild “Unicorn Glow”

I think the Wet N Wild one developed a film so it’s a lot harder to pick up the pigment than it used to be. I remember the colors being a little more pigmented. I do have an extra one from my unicorn box but I kind of don’t want to open it and rather give it to someone who wants it.


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! Forever 21 | I Need This Unicorn

Forever 21 Rainbow Highlighter

This is my least favorite. The blue is just too dark for my taste. The swatches always show the blue a thicker than it is. It’s because I am trying to my get pinky in the purple (which is too small in the pan) and I end up doubling up the blue. Not to mention it’s a large pan! When I stripe it on, the blue is in my contour. It looks ridiculous on me. Also the purple never turns up. It’s showing in the swatches because I forced it to!


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! Ulta Beauty | I Need This Unicorn

Ulta Rainbow Highlighter

This one isn’t included in a lot of the grouped photos because I had already photographed the rest before it even released. At the time of writing this post, it is sold out. But I am sure they will be restocking this.

Of all the affordable brands, (and large pan highlighters) this one I like the best. The colors are actually radiant and the blue is not too dark. However, Chaos still out-glows this one. I also don’t prefer the large pan, its just too big to fit only on my cheek bone. I don’t want my highlighter in my blush and I really don’t want it in my contour area! I know people want large pans because of the better value, but in my opinion, it’s not a practical size.

But the colors are really pretty and I would recommend picking it up if you want a rainbow highlighter and don’t want to spend $20.


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! Love Luxe Beauty | I Need This Unicorn

Love Luxe Beauty What Unicorns Are Made Of

This isn’t exactly a rainbow highlighter. But I thought there may be some interest in this product. It has the many colors of the rainbow, but I can’t exactly call it a rainbow highlighter because it’s not in rainbow order… therefore it doesn’t look like a prism’s rainbow is cast on your face. I also wouldn’t want to stripe this on my cheekbone, especially with the dark blue, but that’s just my personal preference. Though looking at my swatch, it would be pretty as a highlight with just half of the pan, but it all depends on where your blue drops land in your own pan. I think the pan is just really pretty and this can definitely be blended together to use as a highlighter. The color it turns out to be, probably varies from pan to pan because each one is unique.


These seven aren’t the only brands with rainbow highlighters. There are a myriad of indie brands you can find online (especially Etsy). I cannot keep up, nor do I need another one! As far as more known brands, Hard Candy came out with a Trolls one in cute star packaging months ago. I wasn’t able to get that one.

If you already have the ABH Moonchild or even the Aurora palette, you can create your own rainbow using all of the colors in the palette(s).

More Swatches (the Ulta one is not included because it hadn’t released at that point)

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This UnicornRainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This UnicornRainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This UnicornRainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn


The large pans are too big to swatch with one finger. It doesn’t work well that way because the color skips at the joints. And my finger barely touches the purple because of the pan’s lip, which might hurt. So use them with two fingers. And I think they all apply best with your finger instead of a flat brush. With each of them, the color applied more pigmented and even using my fingers. With a brush, most of them got really powdery with kickback. I have shimmery dust of all colors everywhere.

I thought it would be unfair if I didn’t compare the Chaos and Ulta highlighters together, so here they are side by side:

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn

As you can see they are both really pretty and have a glow to them. It’s all up to you what you like on your own face! These will look different on other skin tones. I only come in the one.

Here are photos of them blended out:
Yes, you can see my veins, it’s almost as if I’m a living human being! This is taken under a ring light.

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn

It’s hard to say where which one begins and ends, but in order are: Chaos, Devinah, Bitter Lace Beauty, Love Luxe Beauty. The second photo is Ulta, Wet N Wild and Forever 21.

People like to wear these different ways:
• Stripe it on. So the red/pink is at the top, curving on your cheek bone and it looks like a rainbow is casting on your face.
• Stripe it on and and then blend them together with a duo fiber brush. This way it’s a really subtle rainbow depending on how much you are blending.
• Swirl the brush in the pan. It doesn’t end up a rainbow that way. Depending on which product it is, it may turn out silvery or gold or even blue.
• Swoop it! (Sorry, this needed to start with an “s”.) You can take each color individually and create a rainbow using the pink over the brow, and curving around down to your cheekbone, ending with the violet. I have illustrated it with this photo:

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn

The violet ends too far into my cheek, but there are seven colors to work with here! That’s a lot! My face in’t big enough for this. This look was made with the Anastasia Beverly Hills Moonchild and Aurora palettes. You can use an actual rainbow highlighter and use an eyeshadow brush and dip into each color, one color at a time. And yeah, I didn’t edit this photo to fake flawlessness. I wanted it to be real.


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn
Everlasting Glow and Bronze Over The Rainbow

These two other highlighters are from Wet N Wild’s Unicorn Box, (also sold individually). They’re obviously not rainbows, they’re just striped. That’s nothing new. Bobbi Brown and Physician’s Formula have been doing it for years. I haven’t opened them yet, but I may do swatches on my Instagram or maybe an entire blog post on the box. They look like they’re going to be beautiful, especially swirled. I’ll do swatches swirled and striped. But I probably won’t wear ’em striped cause it doesn’t have the same effect as a standard 7-color rainbow.


Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn

Rainbow Highlighter Extravaganza! | I Need This Unicorn

Disclaimer: This post is not sponsored. Everything was purchased by me, with my own money. All of my opinions are my own.
None of the links are affiliate links. Some links may be broken due to items selling out, or simply the website changed and product had moved to a different page.
If you dislike rainbow highlighter, that’s fantastic, you don’t have to buy one.